fbpx

Introduction

California’s Proposition 19, passed by voters in November 2020 and implemented on February 16, 2021, has redrawn the landscape of real estate taxation and inheritance. With these significant changes, estate planning strategies must evolve to encompass the new tax implications for inherited properties.

Before Prop 19: Property owners could pass their primary residences, and up to $1 million of other property, to their children (or grandchildren if both parents are deceased) without triggering a reassessment of the property’s value for tax purposes Cal. Const. art. XIII A, § 2.

The Mechanics of Proposition 19

Tax Base Transfer

Under Proposition 19, homeowners aged 55 or older, severely disabled, or victims of natural disasters are allowed to transfer their property tax base to a replacement residence up to three times California Board of Equalization.

Example:

Jane, a 57-year-old homeowner, decides to downsize. Thanks to Proposition 19, she can move from her family home in Silicon Valley to a smaller property in San Diego without experiencing a hike in her property tax, even though the market value of the new home is higher.

Before Prop 19:
  • Parents could transfer primary residences to their children without a change in the property tax base. They could also transfer up to $1 million of assessed value in other properties, like vacation homes or rental properties.
After Prop 19:
  • The property tax base can only be transferred if the child uses the inherited property as their primary residence, and there’s now a cap on the assessed value exclusion. Vacation homes or rental properties do not receive the basis transfer.

Inheritance Rules

The proposition modifies the rules around the inheritance of property tax bases California Legislature.

Implications for Estate Planning

1. Impact on Heirs

a) Increased Taxes:

Heirs inheriting properties that are not used as their primary residence or exceed the value exclusion cap will face higher property taxes, which could make inheriting and maintaining such properties financially unsustainable.

Example 1:

  • Before Prop 19: Alex’s parents leave him a family home with an assessed value of $500,000. Regardless of whether Alex decides to live there, rents it out, or leaves it vacant, the property’s assessed value for tax purposes remains $500,000.
  • After Prop 19: If Alex decides not to live in the inherited home, the property will be reassessed at its current market value, which could be significantly higher, leading to an increase in property taxes.

Example 2:

  • Before Prop 19: Sarah inherits her parents’ primary residence and a vacation home with a combined assessed value of $1.5 million. Neither property’s assessed value is reassessed for property tax purposes.
  • After Prop 19: Only the primary residence may be excluded from reassessment, and only if Sarah uses it as her own primary residence. The vacation home would be reassessed at current market value.
b) Selling Inherited Properties:

Given the new tax burdens, heirs may be compelled to sell inherited properties, a shift that could impact family legacies and long-term estate planning strategies.

Example:

Maria, who inherits her parents’ $2 million family home where the property tax is based on a $500,000 assessed value, will face a reassessment if she doesn’t move into the home. The increased property tax could make it financially challenging for Maria to keep the home, prompting a sale.

Implications for Estate Planning Strategies

a. Review and Update:

Individuals and families need to revisit their estate plans to accommodate these changes, especially those plans that include leaving homes to children.

b. Gifting Properties:

Some might consider gifting properties to their heirs before death to circumvent the new rules, though this comes with its own tax implications.

c. Trust Adjustments:

Estate planners will need to consider adjustments to trusts to optimize for the new tax landscape and minimize the financial impact on heirs.

Financial Planning Intersection

Wealth Management:

For wealthier individuals, the intersection of estate planning and financial planning becomes critical. The impact of Prop 19 may require diversifying assets or finding alternative methods to transfer wealth while minimizing tax impacts.

Real Estate Decisions

Downsizing:

Older adults might consider the implications of Prop 19 in their decisions to downsize or relocate, balancing the benefits of transferring their tax base with the limitations imposed on their heirs.

Adjusting Inheritance Strategies

Prop 19 limits the transfer of low property tax bases for inherited properties unless used as a primary residence by the heir, and even then, it is subject to a new value cap.

Example:

Mark inherited a property valued at $2 million from his parents. The original tax base was $500,000. Under Prop 19, if Mark does not use the property as his primary residence, the property will be reassessed at its current market value, leading to a significant increase in annual property taxes.

Navigating the Legal Terrain

Legal Citations

Prop 19 alters the application of sections 2.1 and 2.2 of Article XIII A of the California Constitution, impacting the reassessment rules of transferred property between parents and children or grandparents and grandchildren if the parents are deceased California Legislature.

Expert Consultation

The complexity of the proposition underscores the necessity of consulting with estate planning attorneys to revise and adapt existing plans, ensuring that they align with the new tax landscape while optimizing asset preservation and minimizing tax liabilities.

Conclusion

The implementation of Proposition 19 is a pivotal development with profound implications for real estate owners and heirs in California. It necessitates an in-depth review and, potentially, a comprehensive revision of estate plans to navigate the new tax implications effectively. Armed with informed insights and strategic adjustments, property owners can transition from reactive postures to proactive planning, turning the challenges of Proposition 19 into opportunities for optimized estate management and asset transitions.

For California’s real estate owners, weaving through the intricacies of estate planning can be akin to navigating a labyrinth. However, with strategic planning, understanding of tax laws, and adept utilization of estate planning tools, property owners can ensure that their assets are not only protected but also serve as a legacy for generations. This article will explore the comprehensive steps, legal considerations, and practical examples to optimize estate planning for real estate owners in California.

California Homeowners Should have a Living Trust

Table of Contents

  1. DETAILED PLANNING WITH RELEVANT LAWS
    • Understanding Proposition 19
    • Navigating Federal Estate Tax Laws
  2. HOW A TRUST PROVIDES PROTECTION
    • Benefits of Establishing a Trust
    • Why a Revocable Living Trust is Usually Best
    • Other Types of Trusts That Provide Different Types of Protection
  3. EXAMPLES OF HOW COMPLEX ASSETS SUCH AS REAL ESTATE ARE INTEGRATED INTO INTO ESTATE PLANS 
    • Incorporating a Living Trust
  4. HOW DO YOU KNOW WHICH TYPE OF TRUST IS RIGHT FOR YOU?
    • Revocable Living Trust
    • Irrevocable Living Trust
    • Domestic Asset Protection Trust
    • Medicaid Asset Protection Trust

1. DETAILED ESTATE PLANNING WITH RELEVANT LAWS IN CALIFORNIA

A) Understanding Proposition 19

Under Proposition 19, effective February 16, 2021, California homeowners who are 55 or older, severely disabled, or victims of wildfires and natural disasters can transfer their property tax base to a new residence of any value anywhere in the state up to three times during their lifetime California Board of Equalization.

Prior to Proposition 19, homeowners would be able to pass down real property to their heirs and preserve their tax basis, wholly discouraging people to sell their family property and istead, opt to continue to pass it down from one generation to the next.

Example:

Let’s consider John, a 60-year-old long-term homeowner in San Francisco. His home, purchased two decades ago, has an assessed value of $500,000, although its current market value is $2 million. His annual property taxes are based on the assessed value, leading to substantial savings.

With Proposition 19 in effect, John has the option to purchase a new home in Los Angeles, valued at $2 million, without seeing a spike in his property taxes. He can transfer the $500,000 assessed value (adjusted for the difference in the market price of the two homes) to the new property, resulting in considerably lower property taxes than if the new home were taxed at its full market value.

B) Navigating Federal Estate Tax Laws

As of my knowledge cut-off in 2022, the federal estate tax exemption is at $11.7 million for individuals and $23.4 million for couples, indexed for inflation IRS.

Example:

If Sarah, a homeowner in San Diego, has an estate valued at $10 million, including her real estate, she won’t owe federal estate taxes upon her death, safeguarding her heirs from this financial burden.

2. HOW A TRUST PROVIDES PROTECTION FOR HOMEOWNERS IN CALIFORNIA

A) Benefits of Establishing a Trust

In California, establishing a trust can offer significant protection for homeowners by ensuring their property is managed according to their specific desires and providing a shield against probate proceedings upon death. By placing your home into a trust, you maintain control over the property during your lifetime while designating a successor trustee to manage the property upon your passing. This strategy not only facilitates a smoother and faster transfer of property to your designated beneficiaries but also helps protect the asset from public scrutiny and the often lengthy and costly probate process. Trusts can also offer a layer of privacy and may provide some protection against creditors, making them a wise consideration for anyone looking to safeguard their most valuable asset—their home.

There are many different types of trusts, but the type of trust that is the most foundational for all homeowners in California is the “Revocable Living Trust.”

B) Why A Revocable Living Trust is Usually the Best Option

A revocable living trust is a legal entity created to hold ownership of an individual’s assets during their lifetime and to specify how those assets are to be handled after their death. This type of trust is called “revocable” because it can be altered or completely revoked by the trustor (the person who creates the trust) at any point during their life, as long as they remain mentally competent. The trustor typically acts as the trustee, managing the trust’s assets, which might include real estate, bank accounts, and investments. Upon the trustor’s death, the trust becomes irrevocable, meaning it can no longer be changed, and the successor trustee then steps in to manage or distribute the assets according to the trust’s terms. This setup helps bypass the often lengthy and costly probate process, provides privacy since the trust details do not become part of the public record, and can offer more precise control over the distribution of assets to beneficiaries.

C) Other Types of Trusts That Provide Different Types of Protection

  • Irrevocable Trust

An irrevocable trust is a type of trust where the terms cannot be modified, amended, or terminated without the permission of the grantor’s named beneficiaries once it has been created. Unlike a revocable trust, the grantor, once they transfer assets into an irrevocable trust, effectively removes all of their ownership rights over those assets. This transfer is permanent, providing significant benefits such as protection from creditors and legal judgments, as well as potential tax advantages. Because the assets no longer belong to the grantor, they are not included in the grantor’s taxable estate, potentially reducing estate taxes. Irrevocable trusts are often used for asset protection, to provide for a beneficiary who shouldn’t directly inherit assets due to incapacity or irresponsibility, and for charitable estate planning.

  • Domestic Asset Protection Trust

A Domestic Asset Protection Trust (DAPT) is an irrevocable trust established under specific U.S. state laws to shield a grantor’s assets from creditors and legal claims. By transferring assets into a DAPT, the grantor relinquishes ownership but can still potentially benefit as a discretionary beneficiary, managed by an independent trustee. This structure ensures that the assets are generally inaccessible to creditors and not included in the grantor’s personal estate, providing significant protection while allowing the grantor some level of access to the trust’s benefits. DAPTs are particularly appealing to high-net-worth individuals seeking effective asset protection strategies.

  • Medicaid Asset Protection Trust

A Medicaid Asset Protection Trust (MAPT) is a type of irrevocable trust designed to protect an individual’s assets from being counted for Medicaid eligibility purposes. By placing assets into a MAPT, individuals can safeguard their wealth, ensuring it is not depleted by the costs of long-term healthcare, while potentially qualifying for Medicaid benefits. The trust must be properly structured and adhere to strict regulations, including a look-back period, typically five years, during which assets transferred into the trust may still be considered by Medicaid in determining eligibility. The grantor of the MAPT relinquishes control over the assets and cannot be the trustee, but they can designate who will receive the trust’s assets after their death. This setup allows the assets within the trust to be protected from both Medicaid recovery and other creditors, ensuring that the grantor’s legacy can be preserved for their beneficiaries.

3. EXAMPLES OF HOW COMPLEX ASSETS (SUCH AS REAL ESTATE) ARE INTEGRATED INTO ESTATE PLANS

A) Incorporating a Living Trust

Living trusts are pivotal for California property owners. They ensure that real estate and other assets are passed on seamlessly without going through probate, which can be a public, time-consuming, and expensive process.

Example:

Matthew, owning a beachfront property in Malibu, places it in a living trust. Upon his passing, the property is transferred to his daughter, Lisa, without undergoing probate, ensuring privacy and expediency.

B) Utilizing Gift Deeds

While gifting property can be an efficient method of asset transfer, it’s pivotal to understand the tax implications. The annual gift tax exclusion and lifetime gift and estate tax exemption play a crucial role IRS.

Example:

David gifts a condo in Sacramento to his son, Alex. Given the current annual gift tax exclusion, if the property’s value is within the allowable limits, there will be no immediate tax implications for either party.

4. HOW DO YOU KNOW WHICH TYPE OF TRUST IS RIGHT FOR YOU?

Choosing the right trust for a California homeowner who currently lacks an estate plan depends on their specific goals, financial situation, and needs for asset protection. Here’s a brief guide to help determine the most suitable type of trust:

  1. Revocable Living Trust: Ideal for homeowners who desire flexibility and control over their assets. This trust allows the grantor to retain control over the assets during their lifetime, including the ability to amend or revoke the trust. It helps avoid probate, provides privacy, and ensures that assets are distributed according to the grantor’s wishes upon their death. It’s a good fit if the primary concern is simplifying the administration of the estate rather than asset protection from creditors.
  2. Irrevocable Living Trust: Suitable for those who are willing to relinquish control over their assets for the benefit of asset protection and potential tax advantages. Once assets are transferred into this trust, the grantor cannot modify the trust without the beneficiaries’ consent. This trust offers stronger protection against creditors and can reduce estate taxes, making it a good choice for individuals with significant assets who are also concerned about future liabilities and estate tax implications.
  3. Domestic Asset Protection Trust (DAPT): Appropriate for individuals with substantial assets who seek to protect their wealth from potential future creditors while maintaining some beneficial interest in the trust. This type of trust is particularly effective in states that allow for DAPTs, providing strong creditor protection while allowing the grantor to remain a discretionary beneficiary.
  4. Medicaid Asset Protection Trust (MAPT): Best suited for individuals concerned about future medical costs and the possibility of depleting their estate through long-term care expenses. This trust protects assets from being counted for Medicaid eligibility, but it requires careful planning to comply with Medicaid’s look-back period and other eligibility criteria.

For a California homeowner starting an estate plan, a revocable living trust often serves as a foundational component due to its flexibility and the control it offers. However, if the homeowner is particularly concerned about protecting assets from creditors or ensuring Medicaid eligibility, considering an irrevocable trust, DAPT, or MAPT might be more appropriate. Each type of trust serves different purposes and comes with its own set of legal and financial considerations, so it’s essential to evaluate the homeowner’s individual circumstances and objectives thoroughly. Consulting with a specialized estate planning attorney can provide tailored advice and ensure that the chosen trust aligns with the homeowner’s overall estate planning goals.

Conclusion

Owning real estate in California presents both an opportunity and a responsibility. Through comprehensive estate planning infused with an intricate understanding of state and federal tax laws, property owners can turn potential complexities into streamlined, cost-effective processes that ensure asset preservation and legacy building.

Key Takeaways

  • Stay updated with the evolving tax landscape, including state-specific propositions and federal tax laws.
  • Incorporate specialized estate planning tools like living trusts to facilitate efficient asset transitions.
  • Regularly review and adapt your estate plan, considering the dynamic nature of the real estate market, tax laws, and individual asset portfolios.

It’s crucial to remember that estate planning is about more than just documents; it’s about informed decisions that shape your future and the future of your family. To take your financial organization to the next level and make the best choices for your loved ones. Click here to schedule a Family Wealth Planning Session™ with us. Mention this article, and you can access this valuable $750 session at no charge.

As always, we’re here to support you on your journey toward financial security and peace of mind. Financial planning is a dynamic process, and with the right strategies in place, you can confidently navigate the ever-changing financial landscape and achieve your long-term goals.

If you’re a pet owner, you know the special bond that exists between you and your pets, and to many pet owners, our furry friends aren’t just a pet – they’re a loved and important part of our families. So if you’re thinking about how best to provide for your family after you die or if you become incapacitated, it makes sense for your beloved pet to be a part of the plan.

You want your pet to continue to have the kind of love and care you provided during your life, but estate planning for furry friends requires a little more thought than you might expect. 

To understand why, it’s important to know two things:

  • A pet is considered property under the law.
  • When someone receives a gift of property through a will, that person can do whatever they want with that property, including your pet.

A Will Won’t Cut It

While you see them as part of the family, under the law, a pet is considered personal property, just like your money, furniture, and clothes. Because of this, you can’t actually leave money or possessions to your pet directly through your will or trust. Even if you try to leave money directly to your pet in your will, the money will instead skip your pet and pass to the beneficiaries you named to receive the remainder of your possessions. Or, if you didn’t name anyone else, the court will give your possessions, including your pet, to your next of kin, as determined under the law.

Worst of all, the person that receives your pet and money for its care through your will has no legal obligation to use that money for your pet’s care or to even keep your pet at all. That’s why it’s so critically important to work with an estate planning attorney who knows the proper way to plan for your pet, so that when you die or if you become incapacitated, your beloved companion won’t end up in an animal shelter or given away to anyone you wouldn’t want raising your beloved familiar.

A Will Provides No Guarantees For Their Future

Because you can’t leave money to your pet directly, your first thought might be to leave your pet and money for its care to someone you trust through your will instead. While this is an option, it’s not guaranteed to work.

That’s because the person you name as the beneficiary of your pet in your will has no legal obligation to use the funds you leave for your pet’s care for that purpose. Even if you leave detailed instructions for your pet’s care, there is no law holding the beneficiary to accept the responsibility of caring for your pet or stopping them from changing their mind in the future after the court probate process is finished.

You might be thinking that the person you’d leave your pet to loves them and would never think of abandoning them. But even if this person is committed to caring for your pet, it’s simply impossible to predict what circumstances might occur in the future that could make it impossible for them to provide for your pet for your pet’s full lifetime.

For example, when you die, the new caregiver might:

  • Live in an apartment or condo that doesn’t allow pets
  • Suffer from an unforeseen illness that makes it difficult to care for your pet
  • Have an allergy to your pet you knew nothing about
  • Become so busy with work or family that they just don’t have the time to make a lifelong commitment to your pet’s care

A Will Isn’t Fast Enough

The other issue a will creates for your pet is that a will is required by law to go through the court process known as probate before any of your property can be distributed to the people you’ve named, and of course, it only operates in the event of your death, not your incapacity.

The probate process itself can take months or even years to complete. During that time, your pet could be passed around between family members and friends, who may even argue over who should care for it. In the worst-case scenario, no one may even think to check in on your pet regularly while the court process is unfolding.

Plus, a will only goes into effect upon your death, so if you’re incapacitated by accident or illness, it would do nothing to protect your companion. This leaves your pet in limbo and vulnerable to being re-homed to someone you wouldn’t have chosen or wanted to care for your pet. In the worst scenario, your pet could be surrendered to a shelter by the time everything gets figured out.

Provide Long-Lasting Care for Your Pet Through a Pet Trust

In order to be completely confident that your pet is properly taken care of and that the money you leave for its care is used exactly as intended, ask us to help you create a pet trust.

By creating a pet trust, you can lay out detailed, legally binding rules for how your pet’s chosen caregiver (the trustee) can use the funds you leave for your furry friend. And unlike a will, a pet trust doesn’t go through probate, so it goes into effect immediately in the event you become incapacitated or pass away, whereas a will requires the court process called probate to take place before any decisions can officially be made about your pet.

Additionally, in a pet trust, you can name backup trustees who will receive your pet and any funds left for them if the first person you chose as trustee declines to take your pet or isn’t able to care for them in the future. To add even more certainty to your pet’s future, you can name multiple trustees for your pet. In this way, you’d have two people invested in the care of your pet who can see that the money you leave for its care is used wisely.

Finally, all of the care decisions and financial distributions for the care of your pet will happen in the privacy of our office, in the event of your death or incapacity. We’ll guide your decision-makers about how and why you made your decisions, and how they need to care for your pet to receive distributions. You’ll literally have a lawyer ensuring the care of your pet happens as you would want it. While that may seem excessive for some, we have many clients who care that much about the well-being of their pets and want to ensure their care is handled as they want.

Do Right By Your Pet

Don’t leave your beloved pet’s future up to chance. Let us help you create a pet trust that will provide for your furry friend’s long-term care and be there for your pet and your decision-makers when you cannot be.

At our firm, we can help you create a legally binding pet trust that outlines detailed rules for how your pet’s chosen caregiver can use the funds you leave for their care. Unlike a will, a pet trust doesn’t go through probate, which means it goes into effect immediately if you become incapacitated or pass away. We’ll be there for the people you love when you cannot.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation and ensure you’re doing right by your pet.

This article is a service of Brittany Cohen, Personal Family Lawyer. We don’t just draft documents; we ensure you make informed and empowered decisions about life and death, for yourself and the people you love. That’s why we offer a Family Wealth Planning Session, during which you’ll get more financially organized than you’ve ever been before and make all the best choices for the people you love. You can begin by calling our office today to schedule a Family Wealth Planning Session and mention this article to find out how to get this $750 session at no charge.

[email protected]

858-427-0539